Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black Review: A Cautionary Tale of Durability and Deception

There’s a specific kind of footwear we all need, but rarely give much thought to until the moment of desperation strikes. It’s that humble, unassuming pair of shoes sitting by the back door. They are the first thing you grab to take the bins out on a damp morning, the easy choice for a quick trip into the garden, and the simple solution for protecting your feet while washing the car. For me, the ideal “back-door shoe” is waterproof, ridiculously easy to slip on and off, and durable enough to withstand mud, gravel, and the occasional splash of who-knows-what. The problem is finding a pair that ticks all these boxes without falling apart after a few weeks of use. Too often, budget-friendly options promise practicality but deliver disappointment. It was this exact search for a reliable, no-fuss outdoor clog that led us to the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black, a product that, on the surface, seemed to be the perfect answer to this everyday problem.

What to Demand from Your Everyday Clogs & Mules

A Clogs & Mules is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for convenience and protection in a multitude of casual and professional settings. From gardeners needing a waterproof shoe they can rinse clean, to healthcare workers requiring comfortable, easily sanitised footwear for long shifts, the clog’s simple design serves a vital purpose. The primary benefits are clear: unparalleled ease of access with their slip-on nature, protection from wet and messy environments thanks to materials like EVA, and low-maintenance care. They are the bridge between barefoot comfort and the hassle of lacing up a full shoe, designed for life’s transitional moments.

The ideal customer for this type of product is someone who prioritises function and convenience over high fashion. This includes homeowners, outdoor enthusiasts, professionals in specific fields, or anyone needing a reliable “grab-and-go” shoe. However, a basic EVA clog might not be suitable for those who require significant arch support for conditions like plantar fasciitis, or individuals who need the ankle stability of a traditional boot for heavy-duty work. For long-distance walking or running, specialised athletic shoes are, of course, the only sensible alternative. It’s crucial to match the clog’s capabilities with your intended use.

Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:

• Fit & Sizing: This is more than just picking your number. Consider the width of the clog, especially if you have wider feet. Some designs are notoriously narrow and can cause discomfort, as we discovered during our testing. A good clog should offer a roomy toe box without being so loose that your foot slides around, which can be a safety hazard.

–

• Traction & Sole Performance: The sole is the single most important safety feature. Look for a deep, well-defined tread pattern designed to channel water and provide grip on varied surfaces. The material of the sole itself is also critical; a soft, fast-wearing compound might feel comfortable initially but can become dangerously smooth and slippery in a very short amount of time.

–

• Materials & Durability: Most clogs in this category are made from Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA), a type of foam resin. However, not all EVA is created equal. High-quality EVA is resilient, flexible, and resistant to compression and abrasion. In contrast, low-grade EVA, which we suspect is used in some budget models, feels flimsy, creases easily, and can wear through with shocking speed. The thickness of the material throughout the clog’s body and sole is a key indicator of its potential lifespan.

–

• Design & Maintenance: The overall design affects both function and comfort. Clogs with a solid, non-perforated upper offer excellent waterproof protection but can lack breathability, leading to sweaty feet in warm weather. Conversely, styles with ventilation holes are cooler but will let in water and debris. For maintenance, the smooth, non-porous surface of EVA is a major advantage, typically requiring nothing more than a simple wipe-down.

While the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black is one option in a crowded market, understanding these core principles is key to making an informed choice. For those in demanding professions, investing in a proven, high-quality model is not just a suggestion, but a necessity.

First Impressions: Unboxing the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black

Upon receiving the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black, the first thing that struck us was their incredible lightness. The package felt almost empty. Made entirely from a single mould of black EVA, they present a very simple, classic clog silhouette with a textured panel on the front for a touch of style. The initial impression is one of stark utility. There are no bells and whistles here—just a basic, functional design. However, this lightness also felt synonymous with flimsiness. Squeezing the sides revealed a significant amount of flex, and the sole felt notably thin underfoot. Echoing the experience of another user, we also noticed that one of the clogs had a slight dent near the toe box, likely from being compressed during transit. This suggests a material with poor memory, one that doesn’t easily return to its original shape—an early red flag for durability. The optional security strap pivots smoothly, but the connection points to the clog’s body immediately looked like a potential point of failure. Overall, the first impression was mixed: they looked the part of a simple garden clog, but the tactile feedback raised immediate and serious questions about their long-term resilience.

An In-Depth Performance Analysis of the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black

A product can’t survive on looks and lightness alone, especially one intended for “durable outdoor use.” We put the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black through a series of real-world tests, from gardening and washing the car to general indoor and outdoor wear. Unfortunately, our initial concerns were not only confirmed but far exceeded, revealing critical flaws in almost every aspect of its performance.

Design and Initial Comfort: A Deceptively Simple Start

Putting the clogs on for the first time, the “Pull-On” closure is as effortless as you’d expect. They are easy to get on and off without using your hands, which is a major plus for their intended purpose. The fit, for a standard UK size 9 foot, was largely as expected in terms of length. However, we must echo the sentiment of users with wider feet: the fit is quite snug across the midfoot. If you have wide feet, we would strongly advise ordering a size up or avoiding this model altogether. Inside, the experience is spartan. The provided insole is a thin piece of foam that offers minimal cushioning. As one user aptly put it, they are not “terribly thick” and certainly not “padded/gushy.” You feel the ground more than you would in a premium clog, and there is virtually no arch support to speak of.

A key design choice is the solid, non-perforated upper. This makes the clog completely waterproof from the top, which is excellent for walking on dewy grass or hosing down a patio. Your feet stay dry. But this advantage comes with a significant trade-off: breathability is non-existent. Our testing, which included some warmer days, confirmed that they get very warm, very quickly. Without any ventilation holes, moisture and heat are trapped, leading to uncomfortable, sweaty feet. This is a classic design dilemma in clogs, but the lack of any attempt to mitigate it here makes them unsuitable for prolonged wear in anything but cool weather. While they may be practical, the comfort level is strictly basic and short-term.

The Durability Debacle: Where It All Falls Apart

Here we arrive at the product’s most catastrophic failing: its appalling lack of durability. The claim of being “durable outdoor footwear” is, in our experience, completely unfounded. The first signs of trouble appeared after only a few wears. The thin EVA material across the top of the foot began to show deep creases, making the clogs look old and worn almost immediately. This cosmetic issue, however, was just a prelude to a much more serious structural breakdown.

The primary point of failure is the sole. After just two weeks of what we would consider light use—mostly walking on pavement, grass, and indoor flooring—we observed an alarming rate of wear on the sole’s tread. The material is simply too soft to withstand regular friction. This rapid degradation was confirmed by a multitude of users, with one noting the sole was “wearing through already” after only 16 days of non-continuous indoor use. This isn’t just poor value; it’s a fundamental failure of the product to perform its basic function. Following this, the second predicted failure occurred. While simply walking, the security strap on one of the clogs ripped clean off at its anchor point. Reports of this happening within two weeks, or even after just two wears, are common among user feedback, and our experience mirrored this exactly. The plastic is too brittle and the connection point too weak to handle the slight tension of securing the foot. The materials used feel cheap, and the result is a product with a lifespan that should be measured in days, not months or years. For a product that you can check the latest price and availability on, the value proposition completely collapses when you consider its disposable nature.

The Slip-Resistant Claim: A Dangerous Failure of Grip

Perhaps the most concerning issue we uncovered is the blatant failure of the “slip-resistant” feature. Safety should be paramount in any footwear, but the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black become a genuine hazard as they wear. Out of the box, the tread provides a minimal level of grip on dry surfaces. However, as documented above, this tread wears away with astonishing speed.

As the tread pattern on the sole disappears, it leaves behind a smooth, almost polished surface. When this surface gets wet, the clog loses virtually all traction. We tested this on a damp kitchen floor and a wet patio, and the result was a distinct and dangerous lack of grip. Our findings are tragically underscored by one user who reported, “the spot of the soles is all worn out… it becomes less grip and today I just fell on the floor!” This is not just an inconvenience; it is a serious safety liability. For a product marketed for outdoor and garden use, where wet surfaces are a given, this level of performance is unacceptable. We cannot in good conscience recommend a shoe that actively becomes more dangerous with a very short amount of normal use. The promise of slip resistance is not just unfulfilled; it’s a deceptive claim that could lead to injury.

What Other Users Are Saying

Our deeply negative experience with the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black is not an isolated incident. A survey of feedback from other buyers reveals a consistent and damning pattern of product failure. The sentiment is overwhelmingly negative, with the most common complaints centring on the exact issues we identified: durability and safety.

Many users report a shockingly short lifespan. Phrases like, “one of the bands snapped off within 2 weeks,” “sole wearing through already becoming slippery,” and “Absolutely rubbish… one month of use and sole is completely destroyed” appear again and again. These are not descriptions of a product that has worn out after a reasonable period; they are accounts of a product that disintegrates almost immediately. The issue with the sole’s grip is also a recurring theme, with one user stating plainly, “the grip of shoes is finished… The quality is very bad.” While a single positive review mentions they are easy to pull on, this minor convenience is completely overshadowed by the chorus of complaints about fundamental flaws. The consensus is clear: this product fails to deliver on its most basic promises of durability and safety.

How Do The Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black Compare to the Alternatives?

It’s clear that the Lakeland Active clogs fall short. But what should you consider instead? We’ve looked at three popular alternatives that cater to different needs and budgets, each offering a significant step up in quality and reliability.

1. ChayChax Slip-on House Slippers

The ChayChax Slip-on House Slippers represent a shift in focus from rugged outdoor use to indoor and light outdoor comfort. While also a slip-on mule style, they often feature softer footbeds and are designed more for comfort around the house than for trudging through a muddy garden. For those who found the Lakeland clogs’ insole too thin and unsupportive, the ChayChax would be a significant improvement for casual wear. They are a better choice if your primary need is a comfortable, easy-to-wear slipper for errands and lounging, rather than a dedicated waterproof work clog. They prioritise cushion over the absolute waterproofness of the Lakeland’s solid upper.

2. beister Garden Clogs Anti-Slip Water Shoes

The beister Garden Clogs are what the Lakeland Active Wigton Clogs aspire to be. Marketed specifically with “Anti-Slip” and “Breathable” in their name, they directly address the two biggest failings of the Wigton. These clogs typically feature prominent ventilation holes, making them far more comfortable in warm weather, and a more aggressive, durable sole designed for reliable traction on wet surfaces. For anyone looking for a true garden or outdoor work clog, the beister model is a far safer and more practical choice. They deliver the functionality that Lakeland promises but fails to provide, making them a direct and superior competitor.

3. Crocs Bayaband Clogs

When it comes to the world of foam clogs, Crocs is the undisputed market leader, and the Bayaband model shows why. While they come at a significantly higher price point, you are paying for vastly superior materials, design, and durability. The Croslite™ material used by Crocs is famously comfortable, resilient, and long-lasting. The soles are known for their reliable grip and will last for years, not weeks. For anyone who plans to wear their clogs regularly or for extended periods, investing in a pair of Crocs is the most sensible long-term decision. They represent the “buy it once, cry once” philosophy, offering a level of quality and comfort that budget options like the Lakeland Active simply cannot match.

Our Final Verdict: A Product to Avoid at All Costs

After extensive testing and analysis, our conclusion on the Lakeland Active Men’s Wigton Clogs Black is unequivocal: we cannot recommend them under any circumstances. While they present an attractive low price and the initial convenience of a lightweight, waterproof, slip-on design, these superficial benefits are a mask for critical, disqualifying flaws. The catastrophic lack of durability, with soles wearing through and straps breaking within weeks or even days of light use, makes them a complete waste of money.

More importantly, the rapid degradation of the sole’s tread creates a genuine safety hazard, turning a supposedly “slip-resistant” shoe into a slippery liability on wet surfaces. The product fails to live up to its marketing claims in every meaningful way. In a market with countless better options, there is simply no reason to spend your money on a product that is destined to fail. We strongly advise you to invest a little more in one of the far superior alternatives we’ve highlighted. If you remain curious despite our stern warnings, you can see the full product details and user feedback for yourself, but we believe your money is better spent elsewhere.