IMTY Warm Lined Clogs Review: The Ultimate Winter Comfort Test

There’s a universal, minor inconvenience that plagues us all during the colder months. It’s that moment you need to pop outside—to take the bins out, grab something from the car, or let the dog into the garden. Your feet are warm and comfortable in your socks, but the ground outside is cold, damp, and unforgiving. The thought of wrestling with boots or lacing up trainers for a 30-second trip is utterly unappealing. So, you do the inevitable: you slide your socked feet into a pair of old, unlined clogs or sliders and make a dash for it. The result? Cold, damp socks and a lingering chill. This small, repeated discomfort is precisely the problem the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs aim to solve. They promise the convenience of a slip-on with the warmth of a slipper and the resilience of an outdoor shoe. We decided to put them through their paces to see if they truly are the perfect four-season solution for around-the-house utility.

What to Consider Before Buying Lined Clogs & Mules

A pair of lined clogs or mules is more than just footwear; it’s a key solution for bridging the gap between indoor comfort and outdoor necessity. Their primary benefit is providing instant, insulated protection without the hassle of traditional shoes. They solve the problem of thermal shock to your feet on cold surfaces like concrete patios, wet grass, or chilly kitchen tiles. By combining a waterproof outer shell with a soft, thermal lining, they offer a cocoon of warmth and dryness for tasks that demand quick transitions between environments. This convenience encourages you to get small chores done without a second thought, improving daily efficiency and, most importantly, comfort.

The ideal customer for this type of product is someone who frequently moves between their house and an immediate outdoor space—gardeners, pet owners, homeowners with detached garages, or even busy parents. It’s also a fantastic choice for professionals like nurses or hospital staff who need a comfortable, easy-to-clean shoe for long shifts in cool environments. However, it might not be suitable for those who need high-performance footwear for long-distance walking, hiking, or heavy-duty construction work. For those activities, a proper walking boot or steel-toed work shoe would be a far better investment. The IMTY clogs are built for comfort and convenience, not for conquering mountains.

Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:

• Sizing & Fit: Lined footwear can often fit more snugly than its unlined counterparts. Consider whether you’ll be wearing thick socks and check user feedback regarding sizing—whether it’s best to size up or stick to your usual size. The inclusion of an adjustable strap, like on the IMTY model, can provide some welcome flexibility in achieving a secure fit.
• Thermal Performance: The quality and coverage of the lining are paramount. Look for a lining that covers the entire interior, not just the sole. A thick faux fur or fleece provides excellent heat retention, which is crucial for keeping your feet warm on frosty mornings. The sole’s material and thickness also contribute significantly to insulation from cold ground.
• Materials & Durability: Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA) is a popular choice for the outer shell due to its incredible lightness, waterproof properties, and durability. It’s a closed-cell foam that doesn’t absorb water and is easy to clean. Pay close attention to the construction of pivot points and straps, as these are often the first areas to show wear and tear.
• Ease of Use & Maintenance: The beauty of a clog is its slip-on nature. A removable lining can be a huge bonus for cleaning, though many, like the IMTY, have a fixed lining. In that case, the waterproof exterior should be easy to wipe or rinse clean, and the interior should be quick-drying to prevent odours and maintain hygiene over the long term.

These factors will help you decide if a product like the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs is the right fit for your daily routine. They offer a specific kind of convenience that, once experienced, is hard to live without.

While the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs is an excellent choice, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:

First Impressions: Lightweight Feel, Heavyweight Warmth

Unboxing the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs, the first thing we noticed was their astonishing lightness. At a mere 400 grams for the pair, they feel almost weightless in the hand, a testament to the EVA construction. This immediately sets them apart from clunky, traditional rubber or plastic garden shoes. The black EVA outer shell has a smooth, matte finish that looks clean and understated. Visually, they share the classic, slightly bulbous silhouette of market leaders like Crocs, but the promise lies within. Peeking inside reveals a thick, plush, black faux fur lining that covers every internal surface, from the footbed to the upper. Sliding a foot in for the first time is a genuinely pleasant experience—an instant sensation of soft, enveloping warmth. The fit for our UK Size 8 was spot-on, providing a snug but not restrictive feel, with enough room for a standard pair of socks. The overall first impression is of a well-conceived product that prioritises immediate comfort and practicality.

A Deep Dive into the IMTY Clogs’ Performance

A clog designed for warmth and convenience needs to deliver on several fronts: it must be genuinely warm, robust enough for outdoor use, and practical for daily life. We spent several weeks testing the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs in a variety of real-world scenarios, from damp garden soil and cold garage floors to quick trips to the local shop. Our findings reveal a shoe that excels in its core mission but isn’t without a potential flaw.

Feature Analysis: The Faux Fur Thermal Engine

The standout feature of the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs is, without question, the internal lining. This isn’t just an insulated insole; it’s a complete cocoon of synthetic fur that envelops the entire foot. From the moment you slip them on, the effect is immediate. We tested them barefoot on a chilly 5°C morning on a cold stone patio, and the insulation was remarkable. The thick EVA sole acts as a formidable barrier, preventing the cold from seeping up from the ground, while the plush lining traps body heat effectively, creating a pocket of warmth. The feeling is less like wearing a shoe and more like wearing a ruggedised slipper.

We found this feature to be transformative for those small, transitional moments. No more hesitating at the back door; you just slide them on and go. This convenience was perfectly captured by one user who simply described them as their “fav out the back wear,” a sentiment we wholeheartedly echo. After a few weeks of consistent use, the lining did compress slightly, as is expected with any faux fur material, but it didn’t lose its insulative properties. It moulded to the shape of the foot, enhancing comfort. The only minor downside here is that the lining is fixed, so cleaning requires washing the entire clog and allowing it to air dry thoroughly, which can take some time. However, for the sheer comfort and warmth it provides, it’s a trade-off we found easy to accept.

Built for the Elements: EVA Construction and Waterproofing

The entire outer body of the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs is moulded from a single piece of Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA). This material is a game-changer for this type of footwear. It’s what makes the clogs so incredibly light, reducing fatigue when worn for extended periods. More importantly, it is completely waterproof. Water from wet grass, puddles, or a quick rinse under the tap simply beads up and rolls off. We submerged the toe box in a bucket of water, and the interior remained bone dry. This is a critical feature for a garden or utility clog, ensuring your feet stay dry and, therefore, warm.

The sole is thick and chunky, with a decent tread pattern that provided adequate grip on wet paving stones and indoor tiled floors. While not a dedicated non-slip work shoe, it offered confidence in typical household environments. The EVA construction also feels robust and hard-wearing. The main body of the clog seems built to withstand scuffs, scrapes, and regular use without issue. However, our testing and user feedback uncovered a potential Achilles’ heel: the adjustable strap. The strap itself is made of the same durable EVA, but it connects to the body of the clog via a small plastic rivet or pivot. This single point of connection is the most stressed component of the design. We noted a user who reported their strap broke after only a few uses during a short walk. This highlights a significant durability concern. While our test pair held up fine, we recommend treating the strap with care, especially when rotating it. It’s a design choice that favours versatility over ultimate robustness, and it’s a critical point to consider if you plan to frequently switch between clog and mule mode or rely on the strap for a very secure fit during more active use.

Ultimate Versatility: From House Slipper to Hospital Shoe

The genius of this design lies in its adaptability. The adjustable heel strap is the key to this versatility. With the strap flipped forward, the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs function as an effortless slip-on mule. This is the mode we used most often—perfect for sliding on and off at the doorway without using your hands. They are ideal for shuffling around the house, especially on cold hardwood or tiled floors where the warmth is a welcome blessing.

When you need a more secure fit, for a brisk walk to the post box or while working in the garden, you simply flip the strap back behind your heel. This “sport mode,” as it’s often called, holds the clog firmly in place, preventing your heel from slipping out. This dual-functionality drastically increases the shoe’s utility. The product description suggests them for medical professionals, and we can see the appeal. For nurses, doctors, or hospital staff on their feet for long shifts, the combination of lightweight comfort, a wipe-clean surface, and the option for a secure or relaxed fit is highly practical. The enclosed-toe design also offers a degree of protection required in many clinical settings. This adaptability is what elevates the IMTY clogs from a simple garden shoe to a true multi-purpose piece of footwear that can genuinely serve you in almost any casual setting, indoors or out.

What Other Users Are Saying

The general sentiment from users reflects our own findings: a story of great comfort and convenience, tempered by a notable concern about durability. On the positive side, the feedback is often simple and direct, which speaks volumes about the product’s core function. One user’s concise praise, “My fav out the back wear,” perfectly encapsulates the primary reason most people will love these clogs. They solve a common problem so effectively that they quickly become an indispensable part of a daily routine.

However, it’s impossible to ignore the critical feedback. The comment, “Bought for husband, used just a few times. Just come in from short walk to say strap broke!” is a significant red flag. This isn’t a minor issue; it points to a potential design flaw in the strap’s pivot point, the one area of the clog that isn’t part of the single-mould EVA body. This suggests that while the shoe is excellent for light, slip-on use, relying heavily on the strap for more active wear could lead to premature failure. This balanced feedback is crucial: prospective buyers should weigh the incredible comfort against the potential for this specific point of failure.

How Do the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs Compare to the Alternatives?

The IMTY clogs occupy a specific niche focused on warmth and casual utility. To understand their value, it’s helpful to compare them to other popular options that prioritise different features.

1. Salomon Reelax Slide 6.0 Loafer

The Salomon Reelax Slide is a different beast entirely. It’s a high-performance recovery shoe designed for athletes to wear after strenuous activity. Its focus is on muscle relaxation, with a cushioned, oversized EVA midsole and a soft, breathable mesh upper. While incredibly comfortable, it is not waterproof and offers no thermal lining. Someone would choose the Salomon over the IMTY clog if their primary need is post-exercise foot recovery, breathability, and a premium, athletic-inspired design for indoor or dry outdoor wear. It’s a specialist tool for comfort, whereas the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs are a generalist tool for warmth and all-weather convenience.

2. Crocs Unisex’s Bistro Work Clog

The Crocs Bistro Work Clog is the professional’s choice and a direct, unlined competitor. Its key features are the Crocs Lock™ slip-resistant tread and an enclosed-toe design that meets workplace standards, particularly in hospitality and healthcare. It’s built for safety and hygiene, being incredibly easy to sterilise and clean. The Bistro Clog is the superior choice for anyone working a long shift in a commercial kitchen or hospital where slip resistance and cleanability are non-negotiable. However, it offers no insulation. The IMTY clog is for the person who wants that same clog convenience but with a primary focus on thermal comfort for home, garden, or casual use, rather than professional-grade safety.

3. beister Mens Garden Clogs Anti-Slip Water Shoes

The beister Garden Clogs are essentially the summer equivalent of the IMTY clogs. They are designed with numerous drainage holes, making them perfect for the beach, shower, or hot-weather gardening where you want your feet to get wet and dry out quickly. They prioritise ventilation and water drainage above all else. Choosing the beister clogs makes sense in a warm climate or for summer activities. The IMTY clogs are the polar opposite; their lack of ventilation is a feature, not a bug, designed to trap heat. You would buy the IMTYs for autumn and winter, and the beisters for spring and summer.

Final Verdict: Are the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs Worth It?

After extensive testing, we can confidently say that the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs are an outstanding solution for a very common problem. They deliver exceptional warmth, fantastic lightweight comfort, and the everyday practicality of a waterproof, slip-on design. They transform mundane chores like taking out the bins on a frosty morning from a chilly inconvenience into a comfortable, non-event. They excel as a house shoe that can handle the outdoors, a garden clog that keeps you warm, and a general utility shoe for anyone who values comfort and convenience.

The only significant reservation we have is the potential weakness of the strap’s pivot point, as highlighted by user feedback. For this reason, we recommend them most highly for users who intend to primarily use them in “mule mode” for slipping on and off, with only occasional use of the heel strap. If you are looking for an affordable, incredibly comfortable, and warm clog to make your life easier during the colder months, this is an excellent choice. Banish cold, damp feet for good and embrace the convenience. You can check the latest price and available sizes for the IMTY Warm Lined Clogs right here.